Managing Mild to Severe Depression: A Guide to Treatment Approaches

It is crucial to recognize that none of the available medications or neuromodulation procedures, including electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and psychedelics, are disease-modifying. This means that while these treatments can alleviate symptoms, they do not address the underlying causes of depression. Think of them like acetaminophen for a fever—it may temporarily reduce the fever, but without treating the underlying infection, the fever will return.

Neuromodulation refers to techniques that alter brain activity through electrical or magnetic stimulation. Examples include ECT, transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), and vagus nerve stimulation (VNS), all of which have been explored as treatments for severe depression.

Optimizing Depression Treatment for Different Severity Levels

Given this understanding, how can we best utilize these treatments to support patients during difficult times? The key is to acknowledge that medications and neuromodulation primarily serve as symptom management tools, most effectively used in the short term for severe cases.

Mild to Moderate Depression: Prioritizing Non-Medication Approaches

For individuals experiencing mild to moderate depression, medication should not be the first line of treFor individuals experiencing mild to moderate depression, medication should not be the first line of treatment. Many people can directly link their depressive symptoms to stressful life events. In such cases, the best initial approach includes:

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) – Evidence-based therapy that helps reframe negative thinking patterns. Research has shown that CBT is as effective as antidepressants for mild to moderate depression, with relapse rates significantly reduced in those who complete therapy.
  • Lifestyle Modifications – Regular exercise and a healthy diet have strong evidence supporting their role in reducing depressive symptoms. A study published in JAMA Psychiatry found that individuals engaging in at least 150 minutes of moderate exercise per week had a 25% lower risk of developing depression.

For some, these interventions alone may be sufficient to overcome depression and maintain long-term well-being. If additional support is needed, natural supplements with reasonable evidence, such as St. John’s Wort and S-Adenosylmethionine (SAMe), may be considered for mild to moderate depression. However, these supplements are not without risks—St. John’s Wort can interact with many medications, including antidepressants and birth control pills, potentially reducing their effectiveness. SAMe may cause gastrointestinal discomfort or manic symptoms in individuals with bipolar disorder.

Severe Depression: When Medication and Neuromodulation Play a Role

For individuals with severe depression, particularly those at risk for self-harm or suicide, the risks and benefits of medication should be carefully weighed. Antidepressants and neuromodulation therapies have demonstrated the most significant impact in these cases. When selecting a medication, I prioritize those with a lower risk of concerning side effects, particularly sexual dysfunction. My initial choices often include:

  • Bupropion – A dopamine-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor with a favorable side effect profile.
  • Vortioxetine – Known for its cognitive benefits and relatively low sexual side effects.
  • Mirtazapine – Can be beneficial for those with sleep disturbances or appetite loss.
  • Vilazodone – A serotonin modulator with a lower incidence of sexual dysfunction compared to SSRIs.

It is essential for patients starting antidepressants to be closely monitored, especially in the early weeks of treatment, to assess for side effects and response. Regular follow-ups with a healthcare provider can help adjust dosages or explore alternative treatments if needed.

Treatment Duration and Discontinuation Considerations

For those starting medication, I generally recommend continuing treatment for 6 to 12 months, followed by an assessment to determine whether tapering off is feasible. This process involves shared decision-making, considering:

  • Symptom severity and stability
  • Level of daily functioning
  • Patient’s goals and preferences

The goal is to ensure that the patient has developed effective coping strategies, engaged in therapy, and adopted a healthy lifestyle before considering medication discontinuation. If stopping medication is not advisable, we work to identify the lowest effective dose for long-term maintenance.

Final Thoughts

Depression treatment should be personalized and dynamic, evolving with the patient’s needs. By recognizing that medications and neuromodulation are tools for symptom management rather than cures, we can ensure they are used effectively—providing relief during crises while prioritizing long-term strategies for resilience and recovery.

Heart and Mind: Answering the Call to Psychiatry

Psychiatry as a calling is a profound commitment to understanding and alleviating the complexities of the human mind. It’s more than a profession; it’s a deeply personal journey of compassion, empathy, and healing.

At its core, psychiatry is about connecting with individuals at their most vulnerable, navigating the labyrinth of their thoughts, emotions, and behaviors to help them find light in the darkness. It’s about being a beacon of hope for those grappling with mental illness, guiding them towards resilience, recovery, and a renewed sense of purpose.

Those who feel drawn to psychiatry often possess a unique blend of curiosity and empathy. They are captivated by the intricacies of the human psyche, driven by a genuine desire to understand the underlying causes of mental distress and suffering. They recognize that mental health is not just the absence of illness but the presence of wellness and strive to foster holistic healing in their patients.

Psychiatrists approach their work with humility, recognizing that each individual’s journey is unique and deserving of respect and dignity. They embrace diversity in all its forms, understanding that cultural, social, and personal factors shape one’s experience of mental illness and recovery.

Choosing psychiatry as a calling means embracing the challenges and uncertainties that come with the territory. It means bearing witness to the raw realities of human suffering while holding onto the unwavering belief in the power of resilience and transformation. It means standing alongside patients as they navigate the peaks and valleys of their mental health journey, offering support, guidance, and unwavering compassion.

In a world where mental health stigma still persists, psychiatrists serve as advocates, educators, and champions for change. They work tirelessly to destigmatize mental illness, promote access to quality care, and foster a greater understanding of the interconnectedness of mental, emotional, and physical well-being.

Ultimately, psychiatry as a calling is a testament to the human capacity for healing, growth, and connection. It’s a sacred bond between healer and patient, forged in empathy, nurtured by understanding, and strengthened by the shared journey towards wholeness and healing.

Inflammation: The Hidden Culprit Behind Your Mental Health Struggles

Over the past several years, a growing body of research has highlighted the role of inflammation in the development and progression of psychiatric disorders. A key biomarker frequently used in these studies is C-reactive protein (CRP), which can be measured through a simple blood test. For precise results, it’s important to order the ultra-sensitive CRP test when conducting this in a lab setting.

Recent findings from JAMA Psychiatry have revealed varying mental health trajectories for individuals with low-grade inflammation throughout childhood. Persistently elevated CRP levels, particularly peaking around age 9, were linked to an increased risk of developing psychosis, severe depression, and insulin resistance in adolescence and early adulthood.

This research suggests that a simple blood test could potentially identify children at higher risk for serious mental illnesses and cardiometabolic issues later in life, offering a window for early intervention.

The big question remains: how should we address this low-grade inflammation? My first recommendation is to focus on lifestyle modifications, particularly dietary changes that reduce inflammation, such as adopting a Mediterranean diet. Additionally, I believe chronic stress is a major contributor to inflammation. In modern American society, stress reduction is often overlooked, but finding effective ways to manage stress is crucial to mitigating long-term health risks.

Link to the article: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/2822343

Affective Dysregulation: Understanding and Managing Emotional Sensitivity

When we think about patients who have trouble regulating strong emotions, it often begins with a genetic predisposition toward higher emotional sensitivity. These individuals experience emotions more intensely than the average person. Their feelings are easily triggered by seemingly minor stressors, and it takes them a long time to return to baseline after experiencing these emotions.

These patients frequently encounter more stressors than the average person, creating a cycle where they experience strong emotions, face excessive stressors, and struggle to re-regulate. This combination makes life particularly challenging for these individuals, who typically lack the tools to cope with their intense emotions effectively.

To exacerbate the situation, these patients often live in invalidating environments. They are surrounded by people who don’t understand how distressing it can be to live this way, leading to the development of maladaptive coping strategies. Family and friends may perceive them as “overly emotional or irrational,” dismissing the severity of their emotional states. As a result, behaviors such as self-injury, drug use, eating disorders, and suicidal tendencies can emerge.

Support from family and friends is often only provided once these maladaptive behaviors have escalated, inadvertently reinforcing these behaviors as useful coping mechanisms. By understanding the underlying genetic and environmental factors contributing to affective dysregulation, we can better support these patients and help them develop healthier ways to manage their emotions.

Coping Strategies for Dealing with Intense Emotions

In the fast-paced world of modern healthcare, it’s not uncommon to encounter individuals who don’t fit neatly into specific psychiatric diagnoses. Recently, I’ve noticed a significant number of patients who, despite not having bipolar disorder or depression, still experience considerable distress. Many of these individuals have endured severe trauma, including sexual abuse, and have a history of self-injurious behavior. I refer to these patients as affectively dysregulated, a term that, while not perfect, attempts to capture their unique experiences.

Treating these individuals is particularly challenging because their core symptoms and experiences often can’t be effectively managed with pharmaceutical drugs. Instead, they require intense psychotherapy, which is typically difficult to find and expensive. This situation often leaves affectively dysregulated patients with few options, leading them to engage in self-harm and seek admission to inpatient hospitals. Unfortunately, this creates a vicious and dangerous cycle, as inpatient units are usually focused on acute stabilization rather than providing the long-term care these patients need.

When evaluating these patients, I try to emphasize the limited efficacy of medications in treating affective dysregulation and instead focus on coping strategies, especially during periods of intense distress. Here are some strategies that can be helpful:

  1. Deep Breathing Exercises: Practicing deep, slow breathing can help calm the nervous system and reduce feelings of panic and anxiety.
  2. Grounding Techniques: Grounding involves using the five senses to reconnect with the present moment. This can include focusing on the feeling of your feet on the ground, listening to ambient sounds, or touching a familiar object.
  3. Mindfulness and Meditation: Mindfulness practices encourage staying present and accepting one’s emotions without judgment. Meditation can also help in cultivating a sense of inner peace and stability.
  4. Physical Activity: Engaging in physical exercise, whether it’s a walk, yoga, or a more intense workout, can help release built-up tension and improve mood.
  5. Creative Outlets: Activities like drawing, painting, writing, or playing music can provide an emotional release and a way to express feelings that might be difficult to articulate otherwise.
  6. Social Support: Talking to friends, family, or support groups can provide comfort and perspective. It’s essential to feel understood and not alone in your struggles.
  7. Professional Help: Seeking therapy from a qualified mental health professional can provide structured support and coping mechanisms tailored to individual needs.
  8. Healthy Distractions: Engaging in hobbies or activities that you enjoy can provide a temporary respite from overwhelming emotions.
  9. Self-Compassion: Practicing kindness towards oneself, especially during tough times, can reduce self-criticism and foster a sense of resilience.
  10. Safety Planning: Having a safety plan in place, which includes identifying triggers, safe people to contact, and safe places to go, can be crucial during times of crisis.

It’s crucial to remember that coping strategies are highly individual, and what works for one person might not work for another. Encouraging patients to explore and find what resonates with them is key. By focusing on these strategies, we can provide affectively dysregulated patients with the tools they need to manage their distress and break the cycle of self-harm and hospital admissions.

   Why It’s Important to Thrive and Not Just Survive

We Spend a significant amount of time as doctors monitoring for adverse outcomes. 

We use the absence of disease as an indicator of health. 

But the mere absence of disease is not enough to proclaim good health. 

If we only monitor for the absence of disease, we miss the things that are most important in our patients’ daily lives. 

The things I’ve found to be most important in my life, and often lacking in my patient’s lives are…

Being happy, having a sense of purpose and meaning, and having good relationships which are sometimes ignored if overt signs and symptoms of disease are not present. 

Being “well” is a state of complete mental, physical, and social wellbeing. 

Having a purpose in life is associated with reduced mortality risk, so is life satisfaction. Things like loneliness and social isolation are associated with increased mortality.

When these needs are met people not only live longer but they live with intention. 

Let’s Look beyond the absence disease 

How to Sleep Better: Prescriptions From Your Psychiatrist

I will talk about sedative and hypnotic medications in future videos, but I want to start a discussion on sleep with sleep hygiene. I recommend all my patients start here and follow this process at least 90% of the time prior to talking about medication. I find most patients are not doing these things and if they are it’s not consistent enough to see a noticeable improvement. 

  1. Stick to a routine by waking up at approximately the same time each day. Do this for seven days, and do not alter the time on weekends. This will help you gradually set your internal clock. You have more control over your wake times than your sleep time as you may not feel tired. Try to avoid taking a nap during the day even on nights where you do not get much sleep.
  2. Avoid all caffeine after 12 PM, the effects of caffeine are long lasting and can interrupt sleep. If you can completely stop caffeine that would be best, but at the very least minimize consumption before 12 PM. 
  3. Try to exercise daily (seven days per week), preferably early in the day and not too close to bedtime. Start with 15 minutes per day and gradually work your way up. A combination of resistance training and cardiovascular training is best.
  4. Stop doing active mental work at least one hour before bed. 
  5. Avoid watching TV, using a phone, laptop, or tablet before bed. The blue light from screens has been shown to worsen sleep. The bed should be used for sleep and sex only. 
  6. Create a bedtime ritual to follow every night before bed, warm bath, mindfulness exercise, gratitude journal, reading, or listening to music. 
  7. Do not use alcohol as a way to promote sleep. Alcohol negatively impacts sleep architecture and the sleep you do get will be unsatisfying. 
  8. The bedroom should be dark, quiet, and the temperature should be cool but not cold around 65 degrees is ideal. Consider blackout curtains, a fan to cool the room, and ear plugs to facilitate these conditions. 
  9. Restrict Food and drink 2-3 hours prior to bedtime. This will reduce the chances of sleep being interrupted to use the bathroom.
  10. If you have any pain, take appropriate pain medications prior to bed. 

Why Psychiatrists Don’t Use Lifestyle Medicine to Treat Psychiatric disorders

My clinical experience indicates that most psychiatric disorders would benefit from the use of lifestyle medicine. As a member of the American College of Lifestyle Medicine, I’ve used lifestyle interventions to treat many of my patients. It’s an underutilized and undervalued part of health care in general and these are my thoughts about why that is the case. 

What Can We Do to Help Prevent Alzheimer’s disease (AD)

Introduction

The other day I had a conversation with a friend, and the topic of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) came up. My friend’s opinion was basically why would I want to know I have a disease that results in steady decline in function, and lacks any disease modifying treatments? This is in large part true, there have been multiple clinical trials of both symptomatic and disease modifying drugs that failed to produce adequate results. However, this is a very limitted view and neglects the benefits of focusing on modifiable risk factors and primary prevention. We know approximately 1/3rd of AD cases are due to modifiable risk factors, and the implementation of lifestyle modification early may prevent or delay the onset of AD. 

Modifiable Risk Factors

Common modifiable risk factors for AD include hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, obesity and smoking. Management of these risk factors as early as possible may offer a preventative approach for AD. Equally important are lifestyle modifications such as physical exercise, diet, mediation/mindfulness, and social activity.

Physical Activity

Physical inactivity has a significant influence on the development of AD. Twenty-one percent of AD cases are attributable to physical inactivity. There is a significant number of studies in the literature that indicate physical activity is neuroprotective. We know one of the areas in the brain affected by physical activity is the hippocampus which is involved in memory. Exercise leads to increased neurogenesis and neuroplasticity in the hippocampus. Other benefits of exercise on the brain include increased blood flow, modulation of inflammatory markers, and increased brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). The exact definition of adequate exercise varies in the literature. Any activity that is sufficient to increase heart rate and can be sustained for 30-60 minutes is my definition. A basic example would be brisk walking for 30-60 minutes. Physical activity two times a week beginning in middle age is associated with reduced risk of AD. Aerobic exercise is associated with additional cognitive benefits including improved processing speed, attention, and memory in adults with mild cognitive impairment. This recommendation is especially important for ApoE4 carriers, as exercise is associated with reduced amyloid deposits. 

Physical activity should be a recommendation for all patients without major health concerns preventing physical activity. The earlier in life a patient begins an exercise routine the better. Some of these studies have looked specifically at starting exercise routines in middle age, but there is no reason to wait. The physical and cognitive benefits of exercise are beneficial regardless of age. It’s much easier to begin training when you are young and healthy. If you build healthy lifestyle habits earlier in life, they are likely to last as you age. Guidelines for regular exercise can be found on the American Heart Association or American College of Sports Medicine websites. 

Meditation

Meditation or mindfulness is a topic that is beginning to get more attention in the medical literature. Chronic stress is believed to effect brain structures involved in memory and may contribute to AD. Psychological stress increases oxidative stress and telomere shortening which could contribute to the neuronal loss seen in AD. Meditation has emerged as a possible way to reduce the stress associated with daily life. The techniques of mindfulness involve directing one’s attention to the present moment to reduce the stress associated with constant thinking and worrying. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have shown significant improvements in overall well-being and attention. Improved executive function and reduced inflammatory processes implicated in AD. Additional research and larger RCTs are needed to improve the evidence base. Given the data we currently have there is no reason to not begin mindfulness practices. The techniques are relatively simple and can be learned from a variety of sources. If you are looking for low cost options for learning mindfulness, YouTube has a variety of guided mediations available. I personally like Headspace for beginners because it provides a solid foundation, has a variety of meditation courses, and allows you to track your progress. There is a fee for access to all the courses, but the first 10 sessions are free. Whichever route you choose, spending 10-15 minutes per day practicing mindfulness will lead to a happier and healthier brain. 

Diet

A great deal of research has been conducted over the last several years on the role of diet with respect to cognition. People with high calorie diets, specifically those high in fat are at higher risk for AD. Traditional western diets high in processed carbohydrates, simple sugars, and saturated fatty acids can impact the hippocampus and memory. When Japan transitioned to western diet the incidence of AD increased. Lower calorie diets with lower saturated fat content are linked to lower oxidative stress, decreased Beta amyloid burden, and decreased inflammation. One diet with proven benefits for preventing AD is the Mediterranean diet. This diet is rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, olive oil, and fish. There is moderate intake of low-fat dairy products and low intake of red meat, saturated fats, and sugar. Most of the data supporting the reduce risk of AD with this diet comes from epidemiological studies. Studies have shown combining this diet with exercise further reduces the risk of AD. The Mediterranean diet is associated with better cognitive function and reduced cognitive decline. This is one specific example, but the basic principles can be applied without the need to adhere to one specific named diet. 

Some specific foods you may want to add to your diet to prevent AD include fresh berries which have the highest amounts of antioxidants among the fruits. They are also low in calories and work well in diets where weight loss is a goal. Green leafy vegetables and tomatoes have the highest nutritional value when it comes to brain health amongst the vegetables. Foods high in omega-3 fatty acids are considered to be helpful in supporting brain function. The omega-3 fatty acid most important in brain function is docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), which is mostly found in fish. The anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties of DHA are thought to be responsible for its role in preventing AD. Patients with diagnosed AD are known to have low levels of DHA. Omega-3 fatty acids recommendations from the American Heart association for adults is to eat fish rich in omega-3s two or more times per week. If using a supplement 1-3 grams per day is an adequate dose. Over 3 grams per day, you should consult with your doctor before moving above 3 grams per day. 

Finally, curcumin which is derived from turmeric has anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and anti-amyloid properties. There is low bioavailability of the curcumin lead to mixed results in the initial trials. A new more bioavailable form called Theracumin demonstrated positive results in a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study on memory, attention, and amyloid plaques in older adults without dementia. 

Conclusion

While there is no guarantee that lifestyle modification alone will prevent AD, there are some promising studies indicating it plays a role in the development of this disorder. Most of these interventions are things patients can implement in their lives immediately. They will not only improve cognitive function and lower the risk of developing AD, but it will improve and potential reverse other diseases of lifestyle. 

Introduction to Mindfulness

Mindfulness never struck me as something I could see myself doing on a regular basis. For many years, I viewed the practice as something for “enlightened people” with no practical application for the average person. As the years went on and the research continued to pile up in the literature, I decided to try it out. 

There are two basic ideas to keep in mind during meditation practice. We are not aware of how our body is feeling, and we are not aware of the constant stream of thoughts occurring all day long. By bringing attention to these two things we can begin to take control of our bodies and our minds.

The process is very simple and can be performed from most locations. Ideally you want a quiet place where you will be undisturbed for 10-15 minutes. I personally like the 10-minute mediation session, and it works well if you have a busy schedule. 

To begin the process, find a chair, preferably one you can sit upright in with your feet on the floor and back straight. I like to rest my hands on my legs.

I begin the process with my eyes open, and a few deep breaths in through the nose and out through the mouth. On the 5th breath I close my eyes. I return to my normal rate and rhythm of breathing in through the nose and back out through the nose. 

Next I begin the process of performing a body scan. I like to start at the head and work my way down to the toes, noting any discomfort or tension. I will also take note of areas on the body the fell relaxed and tension free. This should take 1-2 minutes. 

If at any point thoughts pop into your head, it’s fine let them come but most importantly let them go. Do not dwell on any one particular thought, just allow them pass. 

The next step is a series of breathing exercise I learned several years ago. Start with 10 breaths in through the nose and out through the mouth, counting each one. Then perform 10 breaths in through the nose and out through the nose, again counting each one as you go. Finally, take a breath in through the nose, hold it for 5 seconds, and release it slowly through the mouth to a count of 4. This sequence of breathing exercises should be performed two times for a total of 60 breaths. This will take approximately 5-7 minutes. 

For the final 1-2 minutes do not count or breath in any particular manner just allow the mind the space to think about anything it wants to. After a minute or two bring the focus back to the body, feel the feet on the floor, and arms on you lap. Open your eyes slowly, and sit for a minute to think about what you are grateful for before starting your day. It’s an excellent way to practice some gratitude. 

The more you practice this technique the easier it will be for you. As the days go on you will experience more control over both your body and your mind. 

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑