Today’s post is more of a clinical reflection. I’ve been sharing a lot about research studies lately, but I want to pause and talk about polypharmacy in psychiatry and off-label prescribing. Have you ever been in a situation where a patient comes in, and as you review their medications, you see they’re taking a benzodiazepine for anxiety, an antidepressant for depression, a dopamine blocker for psychosis, and a mood stabilizer for mood swings? Maybe even a stimulant for ADHD is thrown in the mix. While I say that with some humor, in reality, this is a common scenario. As an educator, it’s crucial to discuss rational polypharmacy and evidence-based off-label prescribing, as well as the dangers of irrational, off-evidence prescribing.
There are times when using more than one dopamine-blocking medication is necessary in the short term—I’ve done it myself to achieve short-term stabilization—but it would never be my long-term plan. Treatment resistance is another situation where off-label medication, if supported by evidence, could be beneficial. However, if none of these justifications apply and the patient isn’t improving, yet they’re on a potentially risky combination of medications, this is the moment to reconsider the diagnosis. It may sound surprising, but misdiagnosis in psychiatry happens often. If the patient isn’t getting better, it could be because you’re treating the wrong condition.
It’s also possible that you’re addressing a disorder that isn’t the primary issue. For example, a patient being treated for ADHD may have attention and impulsivity problems, but these could actually stem from an underlying bipolar disorder. Since symptoms in psychiatry frequently overlap across multiple disorders, it’s essential to maintain a diagnostic hierarchy in your mind. Sorting out which disorder should be prioritized can often resolve other symptoms that might be masquerading as a different psychiatric condition.
So, if treatment isn’t working and the medication list keeps growing, consider that there may have been a mistake in the diagnosis, or that the focus has been on the wrong condition. Often, many symptoms are driven by a more serious underlying disorder, like bipolar disorder.